Two Represses, Two Different Formats
The Smiths' Best ... I and Best ... II were both originally released in 1992 and have been out of print for years. The current represses split them across formats: Best ... I arrives as a single CD, while Best ... II is a single LP on vinyl. That means the choice is not just which compilation you want, but which physical format you actually play.
This comparison sticks to what the catalog confirms. Neither edition's supplied information includes track listings, remastering details, pressing weight or running times, so treat those as open questions rather than assumed features.
What Each Repressed Edition Confirms
- Best ... I (1CD): Best ... I is a Smiths compilation originally released in 1992, out of print for many years and now repressed as a single CD (1CD). The CD edition gives you the compilation on compact disc without needing a turntable.

Best ... I (1CD) - Best ... II (1LP): Best ... II is a 1LP vinyl edition, part of the 1992 best-of pair being repressed on vinyl for the first time since original release. The vinyl edition is the one to choose if your listening happens on a record player and you want the LP version of the second compilation.

Best ... II (1LP)
CD or Vinyl: Matching Format to Your Setup
The practical difference comes down to your playback gear and how you listen, not to any confirmed audio-quality claim in the supplied catalog.
- Best ... I (1CD): Choose the CD if you play music through a CD player, computer drive or ripping setup. A single disc is easy to store and needs no turntable maintenance. The catalog does not confirm remastering, bonus tracks or disc artwork.
- Best ... II (1LP): Choose the vinyl if you already have a turntable and want the second compilation in LP form. The catalog notes this is the first vinyl pressing since the original release, but does not confirm pressing weight, color or mastering source.
Why These Two Are Not a Straight Swap
It is tempting to frame this as CD versus vinyl for the same tracklist, but the supplied records describe two different compilations: Best ... I and Best ... II. They are companion volumes from the same 1992 best-of project, not alternate pressings of one album. If you want the songs from Best ... I, the CD is the confirmed repressed option here; if you want Best ... II, the 1LP is the confirmed repressed option.
The catalog does not supply track lists for either volume, so check the contents before assuming the two sets overlap or divide the band's catalog in a particular way.
Buying Both: A Sensible Smiths Pairing
Because the two volumes were released together in 1992 and are being repressed together now, buying both gives you the pair in the formats currently offered: Best ... I on CD and Best ... II on vinyl. That suits a listener with both a CD player and a turntable, or a collector who wants the 1992 best-of project represented in the formats the catalog confirms.
If you only have one playback format, the decision is simpler: pick the volume that matches your equipment rather than buying a format you cannot play.
What the Supplied Information Does Not Confirm
These gaps matter before you order, especially if you are comparing against an original 1992 copy.
- Track listings: Neither record's supplied details list the songs included, so compare contents before treating either as a complete hits set.
- Remastering and mastering source: The catalog does not state whether these represses use new remasters or the original mastering.
- Vinyl pressing details: Weight, color and pressing plant for the Best ... II 1LP are not confirmed in the supplied information.
- Packaging and inserts: No supplied details confirm booklets, download codes or special packaging for either edition.


